Hotels near Shelter Island

"Great location "

"Great window views from hotel room. Wish it were closer to food areas. Don't recommend walking alone at night."

"The hotel was excellent except the parking spaces were a bit narrow for SUV and larger vehicles. "

"We upgraded to the Bay View for $25 extra and it was a beautiful view we had a great time there was a restaurant on site and walking distance to the beach and to other outside activities celebrated my daughter's 7th birthday"

"I wanted easy access to views and walking by the water at an affordable price once I was going to spend the weekend in San Diego and I got it. The money I saved covered getting to town when I needed to for my conference. The hotel staff were super helpful and the room modest, clean, and cozy. I arrived early and they were able to get us into a room early. Also at the tail end of my stay, I had an afternoon flight and late checkout was not a problem. I loved being able to walk out of my room and walk along the marina or just go across the street and walk along the ocean side of this narrow island with views into the Pacific. The whole stretch of the island is a park with a wide pathway with periodic flower covered structures that made for great photos! I stayed near the main building with easy access to the large main pool. It was delightful to take an evening swim, just the right temperature and beautifully landscaped. The hot tub was perfect to warm up on chilly nights. I noticed young families enjoying the complementary premium floaties, any kid’s dream come true! I cannot say enough good things about the food! Breakfast, lunch, or dinner were all superb start to finish. I especially enjoyed the omelettes, clam chowder, beet salad, and salmon Wellington, all of which I ordered more than once. They have a divine flourless chocolate cake served with raspberry sorbet that made a perfect treat for my sister’s birthday! And delicious free coffee in the lobby in the morning!"

"Super nice staff, rooms Modest and well kept, clean. Overall well taken care of."

"Very peaceful and lush grounds, executive suite was spacious, and good view of the marina. Check in was easy and quick, staff were very accommodating. Would stay here again!"

"The swimming pool was a little dirty but overall, the place is pretty clean."

"Awesome place. Escape the craziness of San Diego here. Really a hidden gem with a private beach. Thankful for the wonderful experience here."