Shelter Island Car Rental

Search and Compare from Car Companies in Shelter Island

Compare car suppliers to unlock big savings, and package your flight, hotel, and car to save even more.

Members save 10% more on select hotels, cars, activities and holiday rentals. Sign up.Opens in a new window

Enjoy maximum flexibility with penalty-free cancellation on most car rentals.

Beautiful view of the beach with palm trees

Black Friday: Members save 30%+

Members save 30%+ on selected hotels until 4 Dec (property time) with our Black Friday deals. Stay by 15 Dec 2025.

Frequently asked questions

Can I rent a car near Shelter Island?
Yes, you can find a car rental near Shelter Island. No need to depend on public transportation to this or other attractions such as Humphreys Concerts by the Bay — just get behind the wheel and go. Plus when you rent a car, you’ll be able to explore San Diego County’s lesser-known gems that may not be reachable by trains or buses.
What car rental companies are near Shelter Island in San Diego County?
Car rental companies are located across San Diego County, and you’ll find multiple close to Shelter Island. Enterprise is about 6 kilometres from this popular attraction and has some excellent deals. Find them by entering your dates of travel and pick-up and drop-off information. Then, narrow down your search based on your selected car rental supplier. You can also filter your search via exclusive offers, vehicle capacity and more to find your ultimate ride.
How much is car rental near Shelter Island?
Rent a cheap car rental near Shelter Island and plan your break around your own itinerary. With excellent rates from several car rental companies, hitting the streets in your own wheels is a snap with Expedia. Include some filters to tailor your search and lock in the best deal. A few factors that can influence the price include your pick-up and drop-off points and holiday dates.
Which car rental companies have a drop off near Shelter Island?
Enterprise is one of the car rental companies that has a rental car return depot nearby. Drop your rental car at Shelter Island when you’ve finished discovering this well-known sight.
How much is parking near Shelter Island?
Explore your options for parking at Shelter Island by browsing the attraction’s official website. Parking apps can also be helpful when renting a car in an unfamiliar place. Check if there’s any free parking at Shelter Island or if you can secure a spot in advance to save time when you’re here.
Are there electric car charging stations near Shelter Island?
Don’t let a dead battery cut your travels short. If you plan to explore Shelter Island and further afield in an electric vehicle, use apps or websites to locate any charging stations close by. You can also keep powered up during your travels with Expedia’s range of hotels with electric car charging stations.
What is the closest airport to Shelter Island?
About 6 kilometres to the northeast, San Diego Intl. Airport (SAN) is the closest major airport near this top San Diego County attraction. When you pick up a rental car at an airport, you can go from the runway to the highway in a matter of moments and reach Shelter Island sooner.
Where is Shelter Island in San Diego County?
Shelter Island is around 11 kilometres east of downtown San Diego County.
What else is there to do near Shelter Island?
Having your own wheels makes it fun and easy to uncover new places beyond Shelter Island. If you need some day-trip recommendations from central San Diego County, Torrey Pines Golf Course, Torrey Pines State Beach and Black’s Beach are worth fitting into your itinerary.
What time does Shelter Island open and close?
Search Shelter Island’s official website for the most accurate and up-to-date visitor information, including opening and closing hours. Seasonality, special events and weather can impact an attraction’s operating hours, so a little planning will help ensure your visit goes off without a hitch.
Why should I rent a car with Expedia to visit Shelter Island?
Travellers want flexibility, which is why Expedia offers free cancellations on the majority of car rentals. If your Shelter Island plans suddenly change, log in to your account through the Trips portal, click “manage booking” and then choose “cancel this car.” Flexibility is just the start of the benefits of booking your ride with Expedia. Bundle your flights, accommodation and car into a holiday package and save on your entire getaway. And that means more money to spend on the important stuff, like having fun!