Hotels near Mahogany Beach

"A Last-Minute Lifesaver – Truly a Hidden Gem! After a terrible experience at our original resort, we booked this place last minute on the same day we checked in — and wow, what a blessing it turned out to be! From the moment we arrived, we were greeted with genuine kindness and professionalism. Despite the short notice, our room was ready, clean, and refreshingly cool — just what we needed after a long, stressful day. The beds were super comfy, the views were beautiful, and everything about the property felt peaceful, safe, and family-friendly. Once you’re settled in, trust me — you won’t want to leave! The resort has it all: beach access, a relaxing pool, delicious food, and even water activities right on-site. It’s tucked away in a lovely area, so having a rental car is helpful if you want to explore, but they do offer car services if needed. One of our favorite parts was the included breakfast. It wasn’t just your standard grab-and-go — we got to sit down and order from a full à la carte menu with plenty of tasty options. As a family of five, not having to rush out in the morning to find food was a huge plus! Every concern or request we had was addressed quickly by the staff, who were consistently attentive and helpful throughout our stay. After five days here, we left refreshed, happy, and already planning our next trip back. This resort truly turned our vacation around — highly recommend! "

"The wait staff Judy and Eric are awesome. I have been going here for 3 years now and they have always gone out of their way to make me comfortable. Light rain in the morning a few days but cleared up by noon. Drink lots of water bring your sunscreen. This place does not have a lot of amenities but make up in location of being on a beach."

"Staff, food and the Island were excellent. "

"absolutely loved my time at this property. everyone was so nice and welcoming."

"Wonderful place to use a base for diving one of the best dive sites in the world - Mary’s Place!"

"Good"

"I loved how the staff and others on the property were so friendly and accomodating. They all went out of their way to see that we were taken care of and happy. We turned one night into three and made some friends that we will be back to visit with soon."

"I loved my stay here and would definitely come back again! The owners and staff were extremely friendly and helpful in answering all my questions about the area. "

"Supi made us great homemade breakfast, lunch and dinner if we requested. There are also good restaurants nearby."