Independent, Amish Country hotels

"Check in and check out with quick and effortless. Room and hotel looked clean. Bed was comfortable. We enjoyed our stay."

"No bed Bugs! Pleasant night sleep. Wonderful accommodations."

"We only stayed 1 night as a part of a family road trip, but wish we could have stayed longer. Such a cute place! Large, clean rooms. Nice lobby with popcorn machine, coffee and water. Super friendly staff. Nice sitting areas on every floor with books and games. Would definitely return!"

"Second time coming and it was nice just as the first time. "

"I loved everything "

"The place was Great!!! Staff were friendly and courteous. Room was clean, every day even with an extended stay. The staff came around about 10 or so. The whole experience was great, and the pricing on the room was spectacular compared to the other rooms in the area. If I ever go back to Lancaster I would definitely stay there again. "

"Stayed at The Red Caboose Motel in July 2025. I have stayed at this establishment a number of times since 2016. I was assigned to the New Haven Caboose which is one of several Cabooses that received fresh exterior paint last year. Room interior was comfortable with two wall unit A/C units which kept the room cool. Room also featured Cable flat screen TV, coffee maker, microwave, and mini-fridge. I dined at the on-site Casey Jones Restaurant and had a good dinner. The Motel is having free concerts during the Summer on Thursday evenings at the on-site Barn entertainment venue with drinks and appetizers available for purchase. All in all, I enjoy my stays at The Red Caboose Motel and will return."

"We originally booked to stay elsewhere but, on our arrival, we were told we didn't have a reservation, and they were sold out. We happened to stumble on the AVID and we are very happy that we did. The stay was excellent, the staff were amazing, it was clean, all around a great choice. We will be staying there again when we come back to Lancaster."

"Excellent property. Beautiful place!!!"